Passer au contenu principal
Bluvy Tube
Appuyez sur Échap pour quitter le plein écran
Volume m
/
i
Mode Cinéma t
f
/
"I do end up questioning the validity of the scale of ringing that goes on in Britain, Europe and beyond ... it almost feels outdated in a way ... do we need to be luring and trapping so many birds each year?" What do you make of Josh's comments on ringing?

Raccourcis clavier

Espace K
Lecture / pause
← →
Reculer / avancer de 5 s
J L
Reculer / avancer de 10 s
0–9
Aller à 0 %–90 % de la vidéo
Home End
Début / fin
, .
Image précédente / suivante (en pause)
< >
Ralentir / accélérer
↑ ↓
Volume
M
Couper / rétablir le son
C
Sous-titres
F
Plein écran
I
Image dans l’image
T
Mode cinéma
?
Afficher cette aide

"I do end up questioning the validity of the scale of ringing that goes on in Britain, Europe and beyond ... it almost feels outdated in a way ... do we need to be luring and trapping so many birds each year?" What do you make of Josh's comments on ringing?

BirdGuides

BirdGuides

@birdguides.bsky.social

S'abonner
0 vue Publié le 13/11/2026 12:47 1:00
"I do end up questioning the validity of the scale of ringing that goes on in Britain, Europe and beyond ... it almost feels outdated in a way ... do we need to be luring and trapping so many birds each year?" What do you make of Josh's comments on ringing?
8 commentaires
?
B
B @b19735.bsky.social · 13/11/2026 17:48
I agree with Josh. Ringing must cause some stress to birds. How much useful information is actually obtained from it these days? I would imagine that the vast majority of ringed birds fly away and are never seen again. There are techniques that would yield much more useful data such as GPS tagging.
@niallchains.bsky.social · 13/11/2026 14:29
I watch birds and keep a life list. Howver, when I see a bird in the field with a ring on it, I will not count it.
Seriously?!? Have to say, I find that logic completely baffling
@niallchains.bsky.social · 13/11/2026 14:27
I do agree. They call it "in conservation interests" but they treat it like a sport. And you never get to hear of the birds that are harmed or killed during the "ringing" procedure.
As a ringer I’d agree! ‘Basic’ ringing will always be required, but do we need hundreds of people up and down the country ringing Blue Tits in their gardens?! In Scandi only ‘proper’ projects and bird Obs allowed to ring, CES is great for baseline monitoring and training, then specific projects
Most rings are aluminium btw. But yes, ringing studies, when carried out properly, are an essential tool.
Would argue it's more important than ever.
Andy @andii29.bsky.social · 13/11/2026 13:09
Its continuing contribution to science and our knowledge of birds is beyond questioning

Dont get the pushback

Not a ringer btw
I agree 100%!
Why - what essential information about bird populations should we do without?
Voir le post d'origine sur Bluesky
Lien copié dans le presse-papier

Connexion

Il est temps de faire une pause

Ça fait 30 minutes que vous enchaînez les vidéos : accordez-vous 5 minutes loin de l'écran. Levez-vous, étirez-vous, buvez un verre d'eau… Les vidéos vous attendront ici.