Passer au contenu principal
Bluvy Tube
Appuyez sur Échap pour quitter le plein écran
Volume m
/
i
Mode Cinéma t
f
/
... oh, they're LITERALLY supposed to be puppets! | #legendofzelda #tbshorts

Raccourcis clavier

Espace K
Lecture / pause
← →
Reculer / avancer de 5 s
J L
Reculer / avancer de 10 s
0–9
Aller à 0 %–90 % de la vidéo
Home End
Début / fin
, .
Image précédente / suivante (en pause)
< >
Ralentir / accélérer
↑ ↓
Volume
M
Couper / rétablir le son
C
Sous-titres
F
Plein écran
I
Image dans l’image
T
Mode cinéma
?
Afficher cette aide

... oh, they're LITERALLY supposed to be puppets! | #legendofzelda #tbshorts

0 vue Publié le 11/09/2026 10:01 2:38
#tbshorts #legendofzelda
... oh, they're LITERALLY supposed to be puppets! | #legendofzelda #tbshorts
56 commentaires
?
The problem is that it still doesn't FEEL like it was meant to be a puppet play, maybe if they were animated like puppets, it would be easier to suspend the disbelief, but they're animated like just another realistic 3d character, it just doesn't work as well in my opinion.
@witchysylene.bsky.social · 12/09/2026 20:32
And coincidentally enough, Miyamoto loves puppets...And Eiji Aonuma holds a master's degree of the arts in: katakuri. Before he became a game dev, he learned woodworking *and making puppets.* It's how he got into Nintendo! He interviewed with Miyamoto and showed off works. Kind of a cool story.
still looks bad though. good idea, poor execution
Echo!! @echosaefir.com.mx · 12/09/2026 15:07
It reminds me of the puppets used as part of the making for the DQ VII Remake. And I think those gave a lot of the amazing vibes for that game, at least imho.
Jack Sota @jacksota.art · 12/09/2026 03:43
They could've at the very least gave them visibly "mechanical" joints and wooden skin textures.
That... puts a whole different light on the whole thing... but WHY does everything still look so MOIST?!
Because several of the shots in the trailer had the characters standing in the rain and getting wet.
I'd rather have the highly limited polygons than that.
Y tho
It was weird how many people were saying “they look like uncanny puppets” as an insult. Like…did everyone forget about twilight princess!? They’ve done this before and it’s pretty neat. I’ll never understand “they look like dolls” as an insult
They've gone the Dragon Quest VII Reimagined route I guess, but it damn sure worked in DQVIIRI, so it can work here too.
IT GENUINELY MAKES SO MUCH SENSE WITH THE OLD DESIGNS AS WELL LIKE THE REASON THEY LOOK LIKE THAT!!!
as much as I would love stylization to make OoT look more like a puppet show, you need only remember the past trauma of how the public took to the Wind Waker's initial reveal in the early 2000's. If I were Aonuma-san, I'd be a little bit gun-shy about going full-bore stylized vs. simple allusions.
@semudara.bsky.social · 15/09/2026 20:53
Heck, some people still complain about there being cel-shading in BotW & TotK, and that's such a relatively miniscule degree of stylization.
It would have been one thing to devote themselves to this artistic approach for a brand new game. Instead they just opted to make it an OoT reskin, and most people won't know or understand why it looks like that. Living in the age of ugly AI with weird proportions doesn't help.
This might make it click in my head. Thank you.
It would have been even cooler if they were Muppets
Decus Q @decusq7.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 18:25
OH! I was wondering why the characters looked like Action figure versions of the older models.
@panpandacake.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 17:56
I feel that the puppet aesthetic is interesting, but they didn't commit to it at all so it just makes everything worse and it doesn't give the game any style, it just makes it look like they failed at hyper realism
The in-game young link model would probably actually read a lot better if he emoted like in that render instead of not really showing any emotion
Why is no one mentioning that Eiji Aonuma, the producer for the series, was personally hired by Shigeru Miyamoto because he made these exact kinds of puppets? He got the job for his artistry and engineering.
It’d be cooler if there were more wooden textures on the characters to make that distinction clearer

But it does explain why I had a better impression of the trailer since it showed off how the models would look in cutscenes
Let's be honest miamoto did this partially in super Mario 3 with the play theme. I love Nintendo for creative over large profit.
My question is how did it take this long for people to click the pieces together?
Like, I'm not a big Zelda buff, but I thought it was kind of obvious.
If this bothers some people, I hope that we can eventually get mod to remake... Ocarina of Time but everyone is a muppet! 😂

Also never really seen this notion, and it hasn't bothered me, I just like the art style :)
@leothebardo.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 15:30
If the characters are supposed to look like puppets, good, but everything else should reflect that too. The evironments should not look that realistic or natural
fall 🐑📼 @dollparts.live · 11/09/2026 15:06
I think if they animated each movement on 2’s, like a lot of animated movies have been doing lately, the art style would show through a lot more. I’m very biased towards the look being beautiful, but puppetry is hard to go halfway with
It lends to the "storybook" nature of zelda the same way the toy box look of the awakening remake did. Its cool!
Fingers crossed the game gets a "Ask the Devs" spotlight that other recent Nintendo games have received.
This makes SO much more sense. I just wish they'd said that in the Direct and communicated that better in the game/footage itself.

And to the folks saying "It's so obvious!" It's not. Not everyone is familiar with Japanese puppet theater and it's not helped when Link looks smeared with vaseline.
They didn't say it in the Direct because it isn't real, this is just speculation from someone who hasn't worked at the company since 2021
I clocked a vibe that this guy has not had sex
That's why they pay you the big bucks.
Cameroo @cameroo.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 14:11
Oh! Was that way clay models and the like were so prominent in promotion materials back in the 80s and 90s for NES and SNES titles?
Idk, I dont think context for it helps very much, I still see more expression from the Tracy brothers than I do from these models tbh
Thera @therayugnat.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 13:46
Oh nice. I stated in a comment about people comparaison Link with the way less detailed dancing couple, that they were also uncanny to me, looking like automaton.
The weirdest part being the wet skin not looking like real wet skin. It also makes sense.
But the hair are way too detailed !
ok, that's an interesting point ... But the FULL game should have puppet and theater aesthetic then.
@alexvaleriehill.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 12:57
It's aesthetic inspiration (Nintendo has been doing similar stuff for a while with yarn, papercraft and the like), but it's not like they intended to commit to actually emulate OOT as a puppet show (nor should they)
Yes, I agree completely.

They went for the art style while not incorporating any other aspect of the "genre", for want of a better word.

I kinda just wish they'd remake a Zelda and have it look like it's meant to, not "this one is plastic toys" and "this one is puppets"

It's so surface level.
"The cinematography of that format" ARGH
I was getting Thunderbolt Fantasy vibes from some of the designs
mimik @mimikrow.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 11:56
i wish they went further with the puppetry aesthetic because as it is it feels undeceive if it wants to lean into fully realism or puppetry which leaves it looking uncanny at least to me,,
Yeah, definitely. If they wanted to go puppety, then that's cool, but go all in. Animate it that way.
This summed up exactly my thoughts. When I saw the still images I thought they looked like puppets, and all my gripes were the details (like the weird shiny wet texture, and the distinctly non-puppety epona model) that made it NOT look like a stop motion animation
The only thing is... aren't there some NPCs in the trailer that don't look like puppets? Which kinda undermines the whole puppetry look tbh.
Loved the way to explained it. ❤️
@bronzespade91.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 11:32
If we get a Majora's Mask remake, I really hope that Nintendo leans in to a clockwork aesthetic for their character models.

I don't mean to say that they should have exposed gears or anything, but if there was ever a Zelda game that leaned in to the uncanny, then Majora's would be it.
LostAM @lostam.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 11:31
Dark Crystal type of vibes.
I do agree a lower frame rate and stuff would make the style more obvious,

But also I think we're at the point anything under 60 fps is seen as an abject negative and considering how many people already hate the visuals, going further Into them would just make them hate it more :( unfortunately
hmmm...

thinking aloud, i think keeping the camera and ui at 60fps while the characters and effects are at a lower rate would work well, Spider-verse style
WenYan @wen-yan.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 11:10
Video Downloader @down.blue · 11/09/2026 11:11
@bastel-art.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 10:52
Too bad they don't look enough like them
It's not surprising, considering the Link's Awakening remake took huge inspiration from japanese wooden dolls & people were also weirded out by that when it first came out.
I just wish they looked wooden, and not plastic.
Maiko @maikoharri.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 10:41
Já deve ter gente preparando esses bonecos para a Nintendo, e eu espero um teatro recriando algumas cenas😎
@danimilkyart.bsky.social
@faelmds.bsky.social
@andrezzabplays.bsky.social
Mari Izu @mari-izu.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 16:17
Uma série de bonecos de Zelda com qualidade de um Thunderbolt Fantasy seria um sonho
Falando nisso seria legal um teatro de Zelda mesmo
Eu tinha visto essa ideia e tipo, o Dragon Quest VII novo teve essa msm ideia, não foi msm? Que coisa não? Que coincidência hahahaha
Lokey @lokey.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 10:35
kinda wish they spend like 2 mins in the direct to talk about their design choice and inspirations. Would've gone a lot smoother
Tia @thatpinktig.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 12:09
Nintendo never like to 'peek behind the curtains' with stuff like this and it's such a shame.

Especially when instead they set aside a good 3+ minutes of their presentations to talk about how to jump lmao

To be fair though I feel like its all vocal 'outrage' and wont materially affect sales!
Thunderbolt Fantasy fans keep winning
This context makes a lot about the visual direction click into place, but it's a shame we had to get that context from a tweet rather than us being primed for it by Nintendo's marketing. Is this kind of puppetry ubiquitous enough in Japan that it's assumed to be obvious there?
There's definitely a big puppetry influence in JRPG spaces. There's also been some recent shows done in the style of Taiwanese puppet theater so I think the art form is generally more recognizable to a Japanese & some European audiences.
Because it's not real, it is speculation from someone who hasn't worked with the company since 2021
They could talk about it in those dev interviews they do around a game's release
I’ve a feeling miniature arts like Puppetry and Dioramas might be a Nintendo specific obsession or something, as Mario also has a similar obsession but with using traditional Japanese Dioramas as level design inspiration.
I fully agree
I think leaning further into the the puppet theater aesthetic and making it more overt would have prevented a good 70% of the initial distaste and complaints

An aesthetic like this needs to wear its inspiration on its sleeve I feel
Or zelda fans can grow up about different art styles
Making it more overt would also steal the spotlight from it being an OOT remake and make it all about the puppet style presentation; a huge bummer for a 20+ year game remake and hardly worth the price of easing initial complaints of not being what ppl expected.

It's inspiration, not emulation.
Cyboly @cyboly.bsky.social · 11/09/2026 11:59
I would agree but I feel like if the animations were low framerate it would throw a lot of people off, especially if the game was still running at 60, and I know a few people who couldn't enjoy Spiderverse due to its low framerate making them sick in heavy action scenes
Hell, the puppet theater aesthetic could have been an amazing framework for a remake

Imagine a bunch of kids learning about the legend of Hyrule’s greatest hero through a puppet theater show

Just like this remake, those who have witnessed these events now passing down the story to a new generation
They would finally have had a good excuse for low framerate lol

On another note, adapting the game to a stop-motion aesthetic would have been an incredible move and would have made some appealling visuals I think.

So can't wait for mods.
Yeah, plus the original only ran at 20fps in the first place! They could keep a lot of the original animations without interpolation and it'd still look good!

It's not like WW didn't already lean hard into "make the game look like an animation instead of trying for realism"
Esfera @esfera.eurosky.social · 11/09/2026 10:06
@womenvideogames.bsky.social igual te interesa.
Oooh pues sí! El hilo aquel que comentaba de la inspiración sí que lo había visto pero me faltaba el contexto de todo lo demás. En cuanto al detalle de la ropa, creo que en un teatro de marionetas tiene sentido pero quizá aquí no tanto por el contraste que genera con todo lo demás. Veremos 🤔
Voir le post d'origine sur Bluesky
Lien copié dans le presse-papier

Connexion

Il est temps de faire une pause

Ça fait 30 minutes que vous enchaînez les vidéos : accordez-vous 5 minutes loin de l'écran. Levez-vous, étirez-vous, buvez un verre d'eau… Les vidéos vous attendront ici.