Skip to main content
Bluvy Tube
Press Esc to exit fullscreen
Volume m
/
i
Theater mode t
f
/
Did the “gimmick” episodes help or hinder Season 4 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds? Seán, Ellie and Tom give their overall thoughts on SNW Season 4 in their latest WTH Just Happened?! video - OUT NOW! youtu.be/IR0ubO90pMg?... #StarTrek #StarTrekSNW #StrangeNewWorlds #Spoilers

Keyboard shortcuts

Space K
Play / pause
← →
Back / forward 5 s
J L
Back / forward 10 s
0–9
Jump to 0%–90% of the video
Home End
Start / end
, .
Previous / next frame (while paused)
< >
Slower / faster
↑ ↓
Volume
M
Mute / unmute
C
Captions
F
Fullscreen
I
Picture-in-picture
T
Theater mode
?
Show this help

Did the “gimmick” episodes help or hinder Season 4 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds? Seán, Ellie and Tom give their overall thoughts on SNW Season 4 in their latest WTH Just Happened?! video - OUT NOW! youtu.be/IR0ubO90pMg?... #StarTrek #StarTrekSNW #StrangeNewWorlds #Spoilers

TrekCulture

TrekCulture

@trekculture.bsky.social

Subscribe
0 views Published on 01/10/2026 13:11 1:15
#startrek #spoilers #strangenewworlds #startreksnw
Did the “gimmick” episodes help or hinder Season 4 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds? Seán, Ellie and Tom give their overall thoughts on SNW Season 4 in their latest WTH Just Happened?! video - OUT NOW! youtu.be/IR0ubO90pMg?... #StarTrek #StarTrekSNW #StrangeNewWorlds #Spoilers
11 comments
?
@jayrayner1.bsky.social had his views earlier.
Great take. I especially like Ellie's position that while 'gimmick' episodes can be fun, you can't get away with so many in such a short season without it becoming chaotic and directionless.

Maybe the entire season was part of Trelane's project and he was responsible for all the genre switching 😁
I'd love to know what actually went on in the writers' room and what direction they were given.

It felt like they must have been explicitly instructed to not spend too much time with explanations for their plot ideas, as if nobody would really care that much.
Seán, Ellie and Tom. Who are these people? I love all of Star Trek. You say Gimmicks, I say Tribbles, A Piece of the Action, Rascals, Power Play, must I go on?🖖🏽
They tried to be different and i credit that , but when your showrunner has to backtrack on gimmicks on the finale season, it's not a good look. Me personally, I liked the formula I saw in S1/2 . That was peak SNW.
Enjoyed season 4 as a collection of episodes, even though I wish it held together as a more cohesive season

Hopeful that season 5 is more serialised or arc-focused, especially since they went in knowing this would be the last
I've been preaching for years that in order for Trek to survive, it needs more diversity, especially in terms of genre, it needs to break the old formula and embrace multitude of other possibilities. So I'd be a big hypocrite if now I didn't say that S04 of SNW delivered exactly what it needed most.
@saraphxiii.bsky.social · 01/10/2026 15:33
I loved it all. Not a single episode was bad really and I would easily go back and rewatch them all. The mind blowing episode for me was The Griffin Incident. As a huge fan of horror, I LOVED this episode! I get why others, particularly the traditional cerebral sci-fi crowd, didn't like it.
Neither, really! I believe good episodes are good episodes, and good seasons are good seasons. Between 0% and 100% Gimmickiness, I love it all when it's done well.

I felt that S4 was definitely better to watch than S3, but still not on par with what S1+2 evoked in me.
More Muppets, Tribble Muppets, Klingon Muppets all singing, all dancing in full fantasy costume.
Trek has always had gimmick episodes. Catspaw, Rascals, Take me out of the Holosuite. Threshold 😗
Many would argue they weren't all in a single season
I’m watching this as we speak!
View original post on Bluesky
Link copied to clipboard

Sign in

Time to take a break

You've been watching videos for 30 minutes straight: give yourself 5 minutes away from the screen. Stand up, stretch, grab a glass of water… Your videos will be right here when you're back.